I try to limit my criticisms of the left to the issues. I don’t like to make personal attacks on them, even though they do not return the courtesy (who knew, for example, that Pat Toomey and John Boehner are troglodytes). Despite my general rule there are times when I have to wonder about the capabilities or motivations of the left. Here is an example from a recent Wall Street Journal piece.
[Rahm Emanuel] proceeded patiently, to explain. By revealing the memos, with their detailed information on those interrogation techniques (now banned), we had elevated our moral status in the eyes of the world. More important, we had improved our standing in the eyes of potential terrorists. This would undermine al Qaeda, Mr. Emanuel explained, because those interrogations of ours helped to enlist terrorists to their cause. All of which was why the publication of the memos — news of which would presumably touch the hearts of militants around the world — would make America safer.
I can think of only three possible descriptions for this statement: naive, dumb or ideologically anti-American. I think we can all agree Rahm Emanuel is not unintelligent.
So that leaves naive and ideologically anti-American as options. Most likely, the majority leftwing American cosmopolitans (to use Samuel Huntington’s term) don’t believe themselves to be anti-American. Presumably Rahm Emanuel thinks he’s acting in the best interests on the country. So I’ll scratch off ideological anti-Americanism from the list.
That leaves hapless naivety as the explanation for a statement like that. I simply see no evidence supporting Emanuel’s underlying assumptions about the world and our enemies’ motivations. For example, 9/11, Khobar Towers, the African Embassy bombings, the USS Cole, the 1993 World Trade Center bombing and much more happened before the enhanced interrogations, the War on Terror and President Bush. That just is not what motivates Islamist terrorists.
What happens if it turns out that the real motivating purpose behind Islamic terrorism is, as the terrorists themselves say, a fundamental attack on western civilization? If that’s the case, will putting down our spear be viewed as honor or weakness? Will it lead to world peace or chaos as every hostile group and regime moves to fight us because we appear weak and unwilling to fight them?
Unfortunately, I fear we’re going to find out the hard way as the newly empowered left bets our lives that “the world” thinks the way the left does.